Below is a sketch of what is and is not known today concerning Verdier’s two desiderata in positive characteristic.
– **Still open in general.** The naive push‐forward of constructible functions fails (Artin–Schreier shows exactly why), and nobody has exhibited a single “larger” abelian group
G₀^wild(X)
of sheaves (or “functions + ramification data”) on which
f_! : G₀^wild(X) → G₀^wild(Y)
makes sense and factors the usual Rf₁ (or Euler‐characteristic) push‐down.
– **Partial results:**
• For *curves* one can adjoin the Swan conductors at points, à la Deligne–Laumon, and recover a functorial ε‐factor formalism; but in higher dimension—no complete theory.
• Kato and Abbes–Saito have built a very fine ramification theory in higher dimensions, defining refined Swan conductors and characteristic classes of ramification, but so far only at the level of cohomological invariants, not as a covariant group of “wild‐decorated” sheaves.
2. “A MacPherson‐style Chern‐class transformation in characteristic p.”
Here the story is more optimistic, *once one is willing to work with ℓ-adic sheaves (ℓ≠p), smooth ambient varieties, and invert ℓ*.
A) **Singular support and characteristic cycles**
------------------------------------------------
Over a perfect field of characteristic p, Beilinson (in lectures) and—more systematically—Takeshi Saito (in a sequence of preprints) have shown that if
X is smooth over k,
F is an ℓ-adic constructible complex of finite tor‐dimension,
then there is a well‐defined *singular support*
SS(F) ⊂ T*X
a conical Lagrangian; and in fact a *characteristic cycle*
CC(F) ∈ Z_d(SS(F))
of the same dimension as X. Moreover one has an index formula
χ_c(X, F) = ⟨CC(F), [0_X]⟩
and, more generally, a functorial direct‐image theorem for CC under proper maps.
B) **From CC to Chern classes**
--------------------------------
Exactly as in the complex‐analytic situation one may now set
c(F) := c(TX) ∩ 0^! CC(F)
where 0^! : CH_*(T*X) → CH_*(X) is the Gysin map along the zero‐section. One checks (again just as in MacPherson’s original argument) that
c(Rf_! F) = f_* c(F)
in CH_*(Y)[1/ℓ] (or in ℓ-adic homology). In particular, if one takes F to be the constant sheaf on a closed subvariety Z ⊂ X one recovers a cycle which in characteristic 0 is exactly the Chern–Schwartz–MacPherson class of Z. Thus—*under the hypotheses*
• X smooth,
• coefficients in ℚ_ℓ (ℓ≠p),
• after inverting ℓ in your cycle groups,
one *does* now have a MacPherson‐style transformation
K₀(D^b_c(X;ℚ_ℓ)) ––c(–)––> CH_*(X)[1/ℓ]
which extends to the usual constructible‐function formalism once one identifies constructible functions with classes of constant‐sheaf complexes.
C) **Euler obstruction and vanishing cycles**
-----------------------------------------------
The classical “local Euler obstruction” of a variety V ⊂ X at v is recovered in this ℓ-adic/microlocal picture as the *generic multiplicity* m_V(1_V) of CC(1_V) along the conormal T*_V X. One then checks by the usual microlocal argument that for a general linear form ℓ: X→A¹ the vanishing‐cycles functor Rψ_ℓ kills all of those conormals not meeting dℓ, hence
φ_ℓ(m_V(1_V)) = 0
exactly as in the complex case.
3. What one still lacks
– A truly intrinsic “wild” Grothendieck group on which one can push‐forward Euler data without passing to ℓ-adic sheaves and inverting ℓ.
– A fully algebraic MacPherson class c_{SM}(–) defined for arbitrary (possibly singular) X over a field of char p without assuming X sits in a smooth ambient or requiring ℓ≠p and resolution of singularities.
– A “resolution‐free” Nash‐blowup/obstruction‐theoretic construction of Euler obstruction in char p.
In sum: Verdier’s grand vision is now realized in the ℓ-adic, microlocal world (thanks to the work of Abbes–Saito, Beilinson, Laumon, Kato, Saito …), subject to the usual ℓ≠p and smoothness hypotheses and inverting ℓ, but no purely algebraic, wild‐ramification analogue of the naïve constructible‐function/Euler‐characteristic formalism is known without those extra hypotheses.
Was this answer helpful?
version: o4-mini-2025-04-16
Status: UQ Validated
Validated: 8 months ago
Status: Needs Human Verification
Loading model reviews...
Loading reviews...