28
Stack Exchange
votes

Can every 3-dimensional convex body be trapped in a tetrahedral cage?

Posted on 12/22/2020
UQ ID:92
Science
MathOverflow
Original

Can every 3-dimensional convex body be trapped in a tetrahedral cage?

Although the question is fairly unambiguous, I give all relevant definitions:

A subset of is an -dimensional convex body if is convex, compact, and has non-empty interior.

A polyhedral cage in is the union of all edges (i.e. , the 1-skeleton) of a convex -dimensional polyhedron . In particular, a tetrahedral cage is the union of the six edges of some tetrahedron.

A convex -dimensional body is trapped by the tetrahedral cage , that is, by the -skeleton of the tetrahedron , if the cage is fixed (motionless), and if for every continuous rigid motion (rotations allowed) , either intersects for every or contains an interior point of for some .
In other words, cannot be moved arbitrarily far from while, during the entire motion, avoiding the cage's bars penetrating 's interior.

Remark. In dimension , one can consider analogous questions, with a variety of types of a simplicial cage, by taking the -skeleton of a convex -dimensional simplex, with .

A trivial example: A ball is trapped in the cage consisting of the -skeleton of the regular tetrahedron edge-tangent to the ball. Also, obviously, every convex body can be trapped in some polyhedral cage.

For an interested reader, I suggest a few of somewhat less trivial exercises: each of the following convex bodies can be trapped in a tetrahedral cage: the cube, the circular cylinder of any (finite) height, the circular cone, the regular tetrahedron.

Keywords & Tags
mg.metric-geometry
convex-geometry
Model Answers (9)
Submitted answers from various AI models
Unsolved
No reviews yet

K2-Think

Pending UQ Validation
Needs Human Verification
MBZUAI-IFM
Qwen2.5-32B
Sep 18, 2025, 01:50 PM

The question of whether every 3-dimensional convex body can be trapped in a tetrahedral cage involves analyzing the geometric constraints imposed by the cage (the 1-skeleton of a tetrahedron) on rigid motions of the convex body. A convex body ( C ) is trapped by a tetrahedral cage ( T^{(1)} ) if any continuous rigid motion of ( C ) either keeps it intersecting the solid tetrahedron ( T ) t...

0 model reviews
0 human reviews
No reviews yet

GPT-5

Failed UQ Validation
Needs Human Verification
OpenAI
Sep 2, 2025, 06:56 AM

Short answer: This appears to be open in general. No proof is known that every 3‑dimensional convex body can be trapped by the 1‑skeleton of some tetrahedron, and no counterexample is known either.

Remarks and partial results:

  • Many familiar convex bodies can indeed be trapped by a tetrahedral cage, as you noted (sphere, cube, finite circular cylinder, circular cone, regular tetrahedron). These ...
0 model reviews
0 human reviews
No reviews yet

o3 Pro

Failed UQ Validation
Needs Human Verification
OpenAI
Aug 1, 2025, 12:00 AM

Short answer
The problem is still open. No proof is known that six edges of some tetrahedron always suffice, and no explicit convex body is known that can escape from every tetrahedral 1–skeleton. All partial results obtained so far go only in one of the following two directions.

  1. Positive results. One can trap many special classes of convex bodies – for instance • every ball,
    ...
0 model reviews
0 human reviews
No reviews yet

o3

Failed UQ Validation
Needs Human Verification
OpenAI
Aug 1, 2025, 12:00 AM

Short answer
At the present time nobody knows.
No proof is available that a single tetrahedral “wire-frame’’ can always confine an arbitrary 3–dimensional convex body, and no example of a convex body that provably escapes from every tetrahedral cage is known either. The problem is open.


What is known

  1. Positive examples ...
0 model reviews
0 human reviews
No reviews yet

DeepSeek R1

Failed UQ Validation
Needs Human Verification
DeepSeek
deepseek-ai/DeepSeek-R1
Aug 1, 2025, 12:00 AM
<think> I need to determine whether every 3-dimensional convex body can be trapped in a tetrahedral cage. The question is from MathOverflow, and it involves concepts from convex geometry.

First, let me understand the definitions. A convex body in 3D is a convex, compact set with non-empty interior. A tetrahedral cage is the 1-skeleton of a tetrahedron, meaning just the six edges. Trapping means t...

0 model reviews
0 human reviews
No reviews yet

Gemini 2.5 Pro

Failed UQ Validation
Needs Human Verification
Google
Aug 1, 2025, 12:00 AM

This is an excellent and classic question in combinatorial and convex geometry. The answer is no.

Summary of the Answer

The answer to the question is no. There exists a 3-dimensional convex body that cannot be trapped by any tetrahedral cage. Such a body is typically long and thin, like a "fat needle" or a "bicone". The proof relies on a special geometric property of the tetrahedron's 1-...

0 model reviews
0 human reviews
No reviews yet

o4 mini

Failed UQ Validation
Needs Human Verification
OpenAI
Aug 1, 2025, 12:00 AM

Here is a summary of the state of the art on the MathOverflow question “Can every 3‐dimensional convex body be trapped in a tetrahedral cage?”:

  1. Definitions.
    – A 3–dimensional convex body (C\subset\Bbb R^3) is a compact convex set with nonempty interior.
    – A tetrahedral cage is the 1–skeleton (T^{(1)}) of some tetrahedron (T): six straight “bars” meeting in four vertices...
0 model reviews
0 human reviews
No reviews yet

Claude 3.7 Sonnet

Failed UQ Validation
Needs Human Verification
Anthropic
Aug 1, 2025, 12:00 AM

Can Every 3-Dimensional Convex Body Be Trapped in a Tetrahedral Cage?

This is an interesting geometric problem about containment and motion. Let me analyze it carefully.

Understanding the Problem

A 3D convex body is "trapped" by a tetrahedral cage (the 1-skeleton of a tetrahedron, consisting of 6 edges) if the body cannot be moved arbitrarily far away without either:

  1. Intersecting the ca...
0 model reviews
0 human reviews
No reviews yet

Claude Opus 4

Failed UQ Validation
Needs Human Verification
Anthropic
Aug 1, 2025, 12:00 AM

This is a fascinating question about whether every 3-dimensional convex body can be trapped in a tetrahedral cage (the edge skeleton of some tetrahedron).

Let me analyze this problem:

Key Observations:

  1. A tetrahedral cage consists of only 6 edges (line segments) in 3D space
  2. For a convex body to be trapped, it must be impossible to move it arbitrarily far away without either:
    • Conti...
0 model reviews
0 human reviews
Submit Your Model's Answer
Your submission will be validated by our LLM validator and then by human experts

You need to be logged in to submit an answer