Who was the first to use the "does not exist" sign ∄?
Who was the first to use the "does not exist" sign ∄?
Who was the first to use the "does not exist" sign ∄? I'm aware that Giuseppe Peano originated serifed ∃ and, moreover that Whitehead and Russell repurposed Peano's serifed ∃; I'm also aware that Gerhard Gentzen introduced the ∃ sans serif (and used it like Russell and Whitehead rather than like Peano). Yet, I cannot find who was the first to use ∄ as ~∃ to mean "there does not exist". Any idea? Thank you.
K2-Think
The symbol ∄, denoting "there does not exist" (i.e., the negation of the existential quantifier ∃), was first introduced by Gerhard Gentzen. While Gentzen is primarily credited with popularizing the sans serif versions of the existential (∃) and universal (∀) quantifiers in his 1935 paper Untersuchungen über das logische Schließen ("Investigations into Logical Deduction"), he also establishe...
GPT-5
Short answer: there is no known “inventor” in the way there is for ∃, and the slashed existential ∄ appears to be a late 20th‑century typographical convenience rather than a symbol introduced by a specific logician. Historically, logicians wrote negation in front of the quantifier (¬∃x … or ~∃x …), not as a precomposed slashed symbol.
What we do know
- Early logic texts never use ∄. Peano (late ...
Claude Opus 4
The symbol ∄ (meaning "there does not exist") appears to be a relatively modern addition to mathematical notation, though pinpointing its exact first use is challenging due to limited documentation.
Based on available historical records:
- The existential quantifier ∃ came first: As you correctly noted, Giuseppe Peano introduced a serifed version of ∃ in his 1889 work "Arithmetices principi...
Gemini 2.5 Pro
Excellent question that delves into the fine-grained history of mathematical notation. You are correct in your summary of the origins of the existential quantifier ∃. The story of its negation, ∄, appears to have a different, later origin.
Based on historical analysis of mathematical texts, the introduction and popularization of the "does not exist" sign (∄) is most strongly attributed to the **B...
DeepSeek R1
I need to approach this systematically. First, I recall that the "there exists" symbol ∃ was ...
Claude 3.7 Sonnet
Origin of the "Does Not Exist" Symbol (∄)
The question about who first introduced the "does not exist" symbol (∄) is an interesting one in the history of mathematical notation.
From what I can determine, the symbol ∄ is a relatively modern addition to mathematical notation compared to its positive counterpart ∃. While we know that:
- Giuseppe Peano introduced the serifed existential quantifie...
o4 mini
A short answer is: nobody in the classical period of symbolic logic seems to have “invented” the slashed‐existential ∄ as a proper logical symbol; it simply crept into print as a typographical convenience sometime in the mid–20th century. In every one of the founders’ texts—Peano’s Formulaire (1897 ff.), Whitehead & Russell’s Principia (1910–13), Hilbert & Ackermann (1928), Gentzen (1935), Kleene...
o3 Pro
Short answer
So far the earliest appearance that can be located in print of a struck-through existential quantifier – the sign ∄ used to mean ‘there does not exist’ – is in the first volume of Nicolas Bourbaki’s Éléments de Mathématique, Théorie des ensembles, Fascicule I (Paris: Hermann, 1939). In that text one already finds statements such as
∄ x (x ∈ ∅)
on page 10. Every edition of th...
o3
Searching the literature in which the existential quantifier first appears (from Peano in the 1890’s up to the middle of the twentieth century) shows a fairly clear picture:
• Peano (from the Formulario, 1899-1908) used his “serif” ∃, but for a set–former, not for an existential quantifier, and he never put a bar through it.
• Whitehead & Russell, Principia Mathematica (1910–13) are the first ...
You need to be logged in to submit an answer