13
Stack Exchange
votes

Deterministic context-free languages that can be represented as the word problem of a group

Posted on 1/11/2018
UQ ID:44
Science
Theoretical Computer Science
Original

Consider a group . We call virtually free is it contains a free subgroup of finite index.

If is finitely generated by some set one can consider the word problem that is the formal language consisting of all words over the alphabet that evaluate to the unit in .

It is a famous result by Mueller and Schupp that the is context-free if and only if is virtually free.

It is also known that if is context-free, it is deterministic context-free.

My question is: Do we know more about how the class of deterministic context-free languages that can be represented as the word problem of some group, is contained in the class of all (deterministic) context-free languages?

Keywords & Tags
fl.formal-languages
gr.group-theory
Model Answers (9)
Submitted answers from various AI models
Unsolved
No reviews yet

K2-Think

Pending UQ Validation
Needs Human Verification
MBZUAI-IFM
Qwen2.5-32B
Sep 18, 2025, 01:50 PM

The class of deterministic context-free languages (DCFLs) that can be represented as the word problem of a group is exactly the set of word problems of virtually free groups. This class is a proper subset of all DCFLs, as there exist DCFLs that do not qualify as group word problems.

Key Points:

  1. Word Problem and Virtually Free Groups: By Mueller and Schupp's theorem, a group ( G )...
0 model reviews
0 human reviews
No reviews yet

GPT-5

UQ Validated
Needs Human Verification
OpenAI
Sep 2, 2025, 06:56 AM

Short answer Among deterministic context–free languages (DCFLs), those that occur as the word problem of a finitely generated group are exactly the word problems of virtually free groups. This is a very small subclass of DCFLs, constrained by strong algebraic invariances (conjugation, inversion, free reduction). There is no known purely “language–theoretic” intrinsic characterization beyond these ...

0 model reviews
0 human reviews
No reviews yet

o3

Failed UQ Validation
Needs Human Verification
OpenAI
Aug 1, 2025, 12:00 AM

Let Σ be a finite symmetric alphabet (together with the involution x ↔ x –1 ) and let

 F(Σ)=〈Σ〉

be the free group on Σ.
If G is a finitely generated group with generating set Σ, its word problem is

 WPΣ(G)= { w∈Σ* | w̄ = 1 in G } ⊆ Σ* (1)

(the bar denotes the image of w in the group).

  1. What does a “language of the form (1)” look like ?

WPΣ(G) is the kernel of ...

0 model reviews
0 human reviews
No reviews yet

Claude Opus 4

Failed UQ Validation
Needs Human Verification
Anthropic
Aug 1, 2025, 12:00 AM

This is a fascinating question at the intersection of formal language theory and group theory. Let me outline what we know about the class of deterministic context-free languages (DCFLs) that arise as word problems of groups.

Known Results

The Muller-Schupp Theorem

As you mentioned, Muller and Schupp proved that a finitely generated group has context-free word problem if and only if $...

0 model reviews
0 human reviews
No reviews yet

o3 Pro

Failed UQ Validation
Needs Human Verification
OpenAI
Aug 1, 2025, 12:00 AM

Let

 X = {x1 , … , xn } ∪ {x1-1 , … , xn-1 }

be a finite alphabet equipped with the natural involution x ↦ x-1, and let F(X) be the free group on X.
For every finitely generated group G together with the chosen generating set X we have  WP(G , X) = { w ∈ X* | w =F(X) 1 } ⊆ X*.

The question is: inside the class DCFL of deterministic context–free languages, which languages occur as some...

0 model reviews
0 human reviews
No reviews yet

Gemini 2.5 Pro

Failed UQ Validation
Needs Human Verification
Google
Aug 1, 2025, 12:00 AM

Excellent question. This gets to the heart of the intersection between group theory and formal language theory. The class of deterministic context-free languages that are word problems of groups is indeed a very special, and proper, subclass of all DCFLs.

Let's denote the class of languages that are word problems for some finitely generated group as . Let be the cla...

0 model reviews
0 human reviews
No reviews yet

o4 mini

Failed UQ Validation
Needs Human Verification
OpenAI
Aug 1, 2025, 12:00 AM

Here is what is known, and in fact essentially no finer “language‐theoretic” description of the subgroup of DCFLs coming from groups has been found beyond the original Muller–Schupp / Chomsky–Schützenberger style characterization.

  1. Müller–Schupp.
    A finitely generated group (G) has a (deterministic) context–free word‐problem if and only if it is virtually free. In that case (\W...
0 model reviews
0 human reviews
No reviews yet

DeepSeek R1

Failed UQ Validation
Needs Human Verification
DeepSeek
deepseek-ai/DeepSeek-R1
Aug 1, 2025, 12:00 AM
<think> Okay, the user is asking about deterministic context-free languages (DCFLs) that can be represented as the word problem of a group. Let me start by recalling the key results mentioned. The Mueller-Schupp theorem states that a finitely generated group has a context-free word problem if and only if it's virtually free. Moreover, such word problems are always deterministic context-free. So th...
0 model reviews
0 human reviews
No reviews yet

Claude 3.7 Sonnet

Failed UQ Validation
Needs Human Verification
Anthropic
Aug 1, 2025, 12:00 AM

Deterministic Context-Free Languages as Word Problems of Groups

To understand which deterministic context-free languages (DCFLs) can be represented as word problems of groups, I'll analyze what we know from the information provided and relevant theoretical results.

What We Know

  1. A group's word problem is context-free if and only if the group is virtually free (Mueller and Sch...
0 model reviews
0 human reviews
Submit Your Model's Answer
Your submission will be validated by our LLM validator and then by human experts

You need to be logged in to submit an answer