Covering number/Metric Entropy of the unit ball with respect to Mahalanobis distance
Covering number/Metric Entropy of the unit ball with respect to Mahalanobis distance
Let
Consider the following result: let
I would like to know if there are bounds on the covering numbers that are dimension free when we choose the metric to be the Mahalanobis distance
K2-Think
To address the question of finding dimension-free bounds for the covering number of the unit ball with respect to the Mahalanobis distance, we start by clarifying the setup. Let ( B ) denote the Euclidean unit ball in ( \mathbb{R}^d ), i.e., ( B = { x \in \mathbb{R}^d : |x|_2 \leq 1 } ). The Mahalanobis distance induced by a positive definite matrix ( S ) is ( d_S(x, y) = | S^{-1/2}(...
GPT-5
Short answer
-
If S is positive definite (full rank), there is no dimension-free exponent f(S) independent of ε: asymptotically as ε→0 one always has N(ε, B2^d, dS) ≍ c(S) ε−d. In particular, any bound of the form N(ε, B, dS) ≤ C(S) ε−f(S) with f(S) < d fails for small ε. The only “ε–independent” exponent possible is f(S) = rank(S), which equals d when S ≻ 0.
-
What you can get (and what is often...
o3 Pro
Introduce the linear map
T = S−1/2 .
Because dS (x , y) = ∥T (x–y)∥2 , covering B with dS–balls of radius ε is exactly the same as covering the image
E := T B = {y∈ℝd : y = T x , ‖x‖2 ≤ 1} ⊂ ℝd
with ordinary Euclidean balls of radius ε.
The set E is an ellipsoid; if λ1 , … , λd are the eigen–values of S (0<λ1 ≤⋯≤λd) and r i = 1/√λ i , then after a suitable rotation
E = {y : y1 2 / r1 2 +...
o4 mini
First, observe that covering the Euclidean unit‐ball (B_2^d={x:|x|_2\le1}) in the Mahalanobis metric [ d_S(x,y);=;|S^{-1/2}(x-y)|_2 ] is exactly equivalent to covering the ellipsoid [ E ;=;\bigl{,z\in\R^d : z^T S z\le1\bigr} ;=;{,S^{-1/2}x: x\in B_2^d} ] in the ordinary Euclidean norm. In other words [ N\bigl(\e,;B_2^d,;d_S\bigr) ;=; N\bigl(\e,;E,;...
DeepSeek R1
Recall that the covering number
o3
For the Mahalanobis distance
dS (x ,y)= ‖S–1/2 (x–y)‖2, S≻0 ,
the problem of covering the ordinary Euclidean unit ball
B2d={x∈ℝd : ‖x‖2 ≤1}
is equivalent to covering the ellipsoid
E=S–1/2 B2d ={z∈ℝd : z=S–1/2 x , ‖x‖2 ≤1}
with the ordinary Euclidean distance.
Indeed
N (ε ,B2d ,dS)=N (ε ,E ,‖·‖2). (1)
Hence we have to understand ε–covers of an ellipsoid...
Gemini 2.5 Pro
This is an excellent question that combines geometry with analysis of sequences. Let's break down the problem to find the infimum and supremum.
Summary of the Solution
- Identify the Largest Non-Centre Cell: The question relies on finding the area of the largest cell (excluding the central one for odd
). There is strong evidence and proofs for large that the largest non-central c...
Claude 3.7 Sonnet
Covering Number and Metric Entropy with Mahalanobis Distance
This is an interesting question about finding dimension-free bounds for covering numbers when using the Mahalanobis distance. Let me provide a thorough analysis.
Understanding the Problem
The question asks about bounding the covering number
is the unit ball in - $d_S(x,y) = |S^{-...
Claude Opus 4
I'll analyze the covering number of the unit ball with respect to the Mahalanobis distance and explore dimension-free bounds.
Understanding the Setup
The Mahalanobis distance is defined as:
The unit ball with respect to this distance is:
You need to be logged in to submit an answer