How do I find the common invariant subspaces of a span of matrices?
How do I find the common invariant subspaces of a span of matrices?
Let
K2-Think
To determine all pairs ((\mathcal{S}, \mathcal{I})) where (\mathcal{S}) is a linear subspace of the span (\mathcal{G} = \operatorname{span}{G_1, \ldots, G_n}) and (\mathcal{I}) is a non-trivial invariant subspace for every (S \in \mathcal{S}), follow these steps:
1. Understand Invariant Subspaces
A subspace (\mathcal{I} \subseteq \mathbb{C}^m) is invariant under (S) if ...
GPT-5
Let V = C^m and G = span{G1,…,Gn} ⊆ End(V). For a subspace I ⊆ V and a linear subspace S ⊆ G, “I is invariant under every S ∈ S” means S(I) ⊆ I for all S ∈ S.
Key observation (reduction to a rank condition)
- Fix k with 1 ≤ k ≤ m−1 and a k-dimensional subspace I ⊆ V.
- Let i_I: I → V be the inclusion and q_I: V → V/I the quotient map.
- Define the linear map Φ_I: G → Hom(I, V/I) by Φ_I(A) = q_I ∘...
Claude Opus 4
This is an interesting problem in linear algebra that touches on the theory of invariant subspaces and simultaneous similarity. Let me provide a systematic approach to finding these pairs
Structure of the Problem
The key insight is that we're looking for pairs where:
is a subspace of matrices - $\mathcal{I} \subseteq \mathbb{...
o3 Pro
Notation that will be used throughout
V = C^m, M = M m×m (C) ,
G = span{ G1 ,…, Gn } ⊂ M, (1)
A = alg(G1 ,…, Gn ) = the unital algebra generated by G.
For a subspace I ⊂ V denote
L(I) = { X ∈ M : X(I) ⊂ I } (2)
L(I) is a linear subspace (in fact a sub-algebra) of M.
For a fixed I put
Smax(I) = G ∩ L(I). (3)
Obviously
S ⊂ G and X(I...
o3
Introduce the notation
• 𝐺 = span{G1 ,…, Gn } ⊂ 𝑀m (ℂ).
• for a subspace I ⊂ ℂm let
Stab𝐺(I) = { A ∈ 𝐺 | A I ⊂ I } (∗)
(the stabiliser of I inside 𝐺).
The required pairs (𝒮 , 𝑰) are exactly the pairs
(𝒮 , 𝑰) with 𝑰 ⊂ ℂm non–--trivial and 𝒮 ⊂ Stab𝐺(𝑰).
So the whole problem reduces to the following two tasks.
(1) Find every subspac...
DeepSeek R1
Recall that a subspace I is invariant under a matrix S if S(I) ⊆ I, meaning that for every vector v in I, ...
Gemini 2.5 Pro
This is an excellent and deep question that lies at the intersection of linear algebra, representation theory, and computational algebra. The problem of finding all such pairs
Let's rephrase the core problem: For a given subspace of matrices
o4 mini
The short answer is: nothing mystical is hiding here—you have reduced your problem to the study of the module
ℂ^m
over the (finite‐dimensional) associative algebra
A := span_{ℂ}{G₁,…,Gₙ}
generated by your matrices. A subspace I of ℂ^m is simultaneously invariant under every S∈S⊆A exactly when I is an A–submodule of ℂ^m, and then of course any linear subspace S of
S(I) :...
Claude 3.7 Sonnet
Finding Common Invariant Subspaces of a Span of Matrices
This is an interesting linear algebra problem about determining pairs of subspaces with specific invariance properties.
Understanding the Problem
You have linearly-independent complex matrices
is a linear subspace of $\mathcal{G} = \text{span...
You need to be logged in to submit an answer