No – beginning in dimension 3 the two conditions are independent.
There are smooth manifolds which have
• no non–trivial smooth (i.e.
• do admit non–trivial continuous actions of finite groups.
Consequently the absence of smooth actions does not imply the absence of continuous actions.
1–dimensional manifolds
A finite group acting continuously on
Hence in dimension 1 “no smooth action” ⇔ “no continuous action”.
2–dimensional manifolds
For closed surfaces, every finite group of homeomorphisms is topologically conjugate to a group of diffeomorphisms (Kerékjártó, Brouwer, Nielsen).
Thus the implication also holds in dimension 2.
In dimension ≥3 there exist continuous finite–order homeomorphisms which are not even locally linear, let alone smooth. The prototype is Bing’s involution
Bing (1952): an involution
σ :
σ|∂B³ = id and Fix σ is a wild Cantor set contained in the interior.
(For higher dimensions take σ×id on
Because σ is the identity on the boundary, it can be inserted into any
τ(x) = { σ(x) for x∈B^{n}
x for x∉B^{n}
Then τ is a continuous involution of
There are many closed smooth manifolds with no non-trivial smooth actions of finite groups – so-called asymmetric manifolds. Examples in every dimension ≥3 were constructed by
R. Oliver, “Smooth manifolds with no effective smooth actions of a non-trivial finite group”, Proc. Amer. Math. Soc. 74 (1979), 136-138,
and later by Kwasik–Schultz, Puppe–Weinberger, etc. Call one such manifold
By definition, Diff
Embed a small smooth
τ :
Because its fixed set is wild, τ is not topologically conjugate to a smooth (or even locally linear) action. Yet
Hence:
A smooth manifold can have no smooth finite-group actions but still possess continuous ones.
• Dimensions 1 and 2: “No smooth finite-group action” ⇒ “No continuous finite-group action”.
• Dimension ≥ 3: The implication fails; the construction above gives counter-examples.
Therefore, for smooth manifolds of dimension at least three it is not sufficient to rule out smooth finite-group actions in order to rule out continuous ones.
Was this answer helpful?
version: o3-2025-04-16
Status: UQ Validated
Validated: 8 months ago
Status: Failed Human Verification
Verified: 7 months ago
Loading model reviews...
Loading reviews...